Coaching isn't having the same conversation 14 times.

Every restaurant I’ve ever worked with has a Mike. He’s the employee who has been warned about showing up late. He’s been told to follow the recipe. Mike and his manager have had the same conversation so many times they could both recite it from memory. Yet Mike continues to be on the schedule because the owner can’t figure out who else would work sauté on Friday night. How can you avoid the Mikes?

Stop comparing the employee to an empty shift

When restaurant owners decide whether to keep a problem employee, they compare that person to having nobody at all. That’s the wrong comparison. The real question is: What is this person costing my entire team?

That cost never shows up on your P&L. There’s no line item for your best cook getting fed up or your manager losing credibility because everyone knows Mike gets away with things nobody else does. But those costs are real, and they compound. When one person shows up late with no consequence, everyone else starts wondering why they bother being on time. When one person ignores the recipe, the cook who follows it starts to feel like a sucker.

Culture isn’t what you put on the wall. Culture is what you allow.

Run every problem through “know, can, choose”

In some cases, you don’t have the wrong employees. Instead, you have an employee who doesn’t know what’s expected of them. The best way to determine if an employee is the wrong person, ask three questions.

Do they know the standard? If you haven’t made the expectation clear, trained it and shown them what “good” looks like, that’s not an employee failure. It’s a leadership failure. Teach them.

Can they meet the standard? Some people know exactly what’s expected but can’t perform at that level yet. That calls for more training, more practice or more time. Sometimes it means a different role. A great server may never be a great manager, and a great line cook may not belong in the sous chef job.

Do they choose to meet the standard? If they know the closing checklist, can complete it and decide not to, you don’t have a training problem. You have a choice, and choices require accountability.

Know when coaching turns into tolerating

I’m not telling you to fire someone for their first mistake. Everyone screws up, and people deserve feedback and coaching.

But coaching isn’t having the same conversation 14 times. Every time you repeat it with no change and no consequence, you teach that employee your words don’t mean anything and the only consequence is another conversation. At that point, you’re not coaching. You’re tolerating.

Back up your managers

If you tell your managers to hold the team accountable and then step in with “We really need them this weekend,” you’ve just taught your managers not to manage. Do that a few times, and six months from now you’ll wonder why nobody on your management team confronts anyone.

You can’t tell managers they own the result and then take away their authority the moment it gets uncomfortable. That’s pretend delegation.

Accept the short-term pain

Being short-staffed is not a strategy, and it’s not fun. You may have to cut hours, close a section or work a shift yourself. But temporary pain is very different from permanent dysfunction.

Usually, you’ll find when the wrong person finally goes, the team gets lighter and shifts get calmer. Productivity can actually go up with fewer people, because one toxic or unreliable employee can create more work than they accomplish.

Put your Mike through the test

You already know who your Mike is. Run that person through “know, can, choose” today. If they don’t know, fix the clarity. If they can’t, decide whether more training or a different role makes sense. If they know, they can and they keep choosing not to, stop pretending you have a training problem.

Your job isn’t to keep every employee. Your job is to build a team that executes your standards without you fixing everything. Sometimes that means one empty spot on the schedule is less dangerous than the wrong person filling it.

David Scott Peters is a restaurant industry veteran and the original restaurant coach. He’s spent decades perfecting the systems that helped thousands of independent restaurants reclaim their profits and freedom. His book, “Restaurant Prosperity Formula: What Successful Restaurateurs Do,” teaches the systems and traits restaurant owners must develop to run a profitable restaurant. Learn more about his expertise and coaching programs at http://www.davidscottpeters.com. 

Expert Takes, Feature, Labor & Employees