A catering order might have just one name on the receipt, but think about everyone sitting around the table. How many of those people have never visited your restaurant? How many are experiencing your food for the first time?
That’s what makes catering such an interesting opportunity for full-service restaurants. It’s a chance to introduce your brand to an entire room of new guests and earn their future visits—but that’s determined by if you get the experience right.
Of course, that takes more than putting larger portions of your regular menu into aluminum trays. Food needs to travel well, and thoughtful packaging is a key piece of that puzzle. But the equation also includes your team members, who need clear processes and training to execute at a high level.
Oh and also, none of this can come at the expense of the guests in your dining room.
That’s why catering is such a challenge that many operators simply put off until they realize what an incredible revenue stream it can be, and then quickly scramble to find the answers to what makes a good catering program tick.
In a recent webinar, FSR sat down with Jordan Johnson, director of off premise at Firebirds Wood Fired Grill, to learn how she built the structure behind the brand’s catering program that has successfully scaled across 70+ locations in 23 states.
WATCH THE ENTIRE WEBINAR ON DEMAND HERE.
When Johnson joined Firebirds in 2022, demand was already there. Guests were asking for catering, and operators were finding ways to accommodate them. The task was to turn that existing business into a consistent program that could work across the system.

Johnson unpacked the work behind that effort, from testing packaging in Charlotte to helping individual restaurants capture more business without overextending their kitchens. Here are five learnings from the webinar for full-service operators looking to build or strengthen their own catering playbooks.
1. Prove the demand, then build the infrastructure.
Firebirds didn’t start with the question of whether guests wanted catering. Operators, sales data, reviews, and incoming inquiries had already supplied the answer.
“Our goal was to hone in on that and make it a scalable program for us, a scalable channel for us,” Johnson says.
For restaurants seeking leadership buy-in, she recommends documenting the business already knocking on the door: phone calls, emails, large orders, and sales generated without a formal catering system. Those requests can help make the case for dedicated resources.
However, demand is only half the equation. Johnson also puts technology near the top of her catering launch checklist. Operators need to understand whether their ordering platforms and existing systems can support catering without creating a mountain of manual work.
At Firebirds, that meant working through menu integration and getting orders to flow into the POS. The playbook also addresses what happens when an order doesn’t reach the system as intended.
The takeaway: Start with evidence of what guests want and a clear understanding of what the restaurant can execute. The finer details of delivery settings and promotional assets can follow.
2. Build the playbook in a working restaurant—not just a test kitchen.
Firebirds’ research and development kitchen gave the team a place to test food, packaging, and presentation before expanding the program. But Johnson knew a controlled environment couldn’t answer every operational question.
Early in her tenure, she spent several months working at a restaurant to understand its off-premises flow. Where was packaging stored relative to the pickup window? How easy was it to retrieve branded materials? Would filling a catering beverage order put someone in the way of regular service?
Those observations helped shape a program grounded in the realities of a full-service kitchen.
The same approach applies to capacity. Firebirds initially established parameters around lead times and delivery minimums, then adjusted as operators demonstrated what their locations could handle. Some teams have asked for shorter lead times to capture more orders. When operational issues arise, the response may be to extend lead times or temporarily pause availability.
Consistency doesn’t mean ignoring differences in readiness. It means maintaining brand standards while giving restaurants the support and guardrails to deliver them.
3. Make the menu and packaging pass the road test.
A dish that shines in the dining room doesn’t automatically belong on a catering menu.
Firebirds started with a scaled-back selection, drawing in part from items that already performed well in its family meals business. From there, guest feedback, operator input, and sales data helped determine what stayed, what changed, and what needed a different packaging solution.
The testing was comprehensive. Johnson and her team loaded food into vehicles and drove it around to assess temperature, texture, and presentation. Was the steak still tender? Had the salad shifted during the trip?
Not every problem required cutting an item. Sometimes, the fix was finding a better way to keep it secure in transit.
Branding mattered, too. Firebirds wanted packaging that reflected its polished-casual positioning, while Johnson encouraged operators to consider accessible starting points such as logo stickers, branded parchment, and catering menus tucked into bags.
The goal is to protect both the food and the introduction it makes. For someone encountering the brand for the first time at an office lunch, that package is part of the restaurant experience.
4. Give local outreach a specific audience—and a specific plan.
Catering sales don’t begin and end with a marketplace listing.
Firebirds built on an existing local store marketing program, tapping brand ambassadors and restaurant team members to introduce its offerings to nearby businesses. Home office support helps those teams troubleshoot issues and develop plans suited to their markets.
Johnson’s advice is to make that outreach intentional. Identify where the ambassador is going, who they need to meet, and what the visit should accomplish.
The audience may be different from the restaurant’s typical dine-in guest. Administrative assistants, receptionists, HR managers, and pharmaceutical representatives can all influence group orders.
Listening to those customers can also reveal operational opportunities. At Firebirds, teams noticed guests placing orders for 11 a.m., then calling to request earlier pickup because their lunches began at that time. That feedback helped prompt earlier catering availability, including 10:30 a.m. at many locations.
Rather than repeatedly handling the same exception, the brand changed the offering to better fit the occasion.
5. Earn the repeat order before paying for the next one.
Sales and average order value matter, but Johnson looks closely at new guests and repeat business to understand the health of the channel.
A large, one-time celebration can boost sales without signaling a recurring revenue stream. Regular business lunches and meetings offer a different view of whether the program is building lasting relationships.
When repeat ordering softens, Johnson recommends checking execution first. Missing items, incorrect orders, late food, temperature issues, and a difficult online ordering experience can all undermine retention.
Paid visibility won’t solve those problems.
“It would be a shame to see that investment get used if the operational needs aren’t being met,” she says.
Accountability also extends beyond the restaurant’s doors. Firebirds uses packing checklists and partner-enabled photography to help document orders at handoff and delivery. When something goes wrong, those records help teams establish what happened and focus on making it right—not assigning blame.
For Johnson, that’s the foundation of a sustainable catering business: staying close to operators, listening to guests, and treating execution as the prerequisite for growth. Winning the first order creates the opportunity. Delivering on it gives the guest a reason to come back.
Watch the rest of the webinar HERE.
Stay in the loop and click HERE to receive invites for future webinars by signing up for our e-letters.