The NextGen resort restaurant experience is interactive and memorable—like guests choosing their own "blade" or knife when ordering a steak at Blade & Barrel.

Justin Draper is feeding the fantasy for guests at Dellshire Resort, where he balances elevated dishes in a medieval setting—without being themed to the point of being tacky or garish. Yes, there may be a giant 70-foot fire-breathing dragon named Golspar at the entrance, but that doesn’t mean the dining experiences inside the six distinct venues aren’t elevated and culinary-driven.  

The first-of-its-kind resort opened this spring in Wisconsin Dells as one of the region’s most highly anticipated new hospitality destinations, blending medieval fantasy-inspired storytelling with the refined style of an upscale Midwestern retreat. Visitors step inside the two-story entrance framed by cathedral windows to find a castle brought to life, with stone masonry and sculptural corbels transporting them to a different time.  

Justin Draper headshot.
As culinary director at Dellshire Resort, Justin Draper oversees all food and beverage venues both on- and off-site.

A third-generation Wisconsin Dells chef, Draper took up the mantle following his role as executive chef and co-culinary director at Dawn Manor, which is now part of the Dellshire Resort collection. Located just minutes down the road, Dawn Manor is housed in a restored 19th century mansion overlooking Mirror Lake. The classy supper club has five period-themed private dining rooms, plus a downstairs speakeasy offering Prohibition-era cocktails and live entertainment. 

Draper oversees all food and beverage venues both on- and off-site, working closely with chefs to develop menus, guide kitchen teams, and ensure that each outlet delivers creativity, consistency, and a lasting experience for every guest.  

“The neat thing is that we have a zone or an experience for any occasion,” Draper says. “Dining is designed to feel like part of the adventure inside of Dellshire. We use imaginative concepts, presenting and storytelling to create that memorable experience.” 

The culinary program at Dellshire is anchored by the signature restaurant Blade & Barrel, featuring Wisconsin classics, alongside The Thirsty Dragon, a cozy fireside lounge; Scale Cove at Serpent’s Bay, a poolside swim-up bar; Kettle & Keep, a café and marketplace; and Gilded Spouts, located within the resort’s entertainment hub, Hero’s Hall. Each concept, from tavern-style dining to cocktails and hidden speakeasy moments, is designed to deepen the sense of exploration for guests.  

Draper is one of five F&B leaders featured in our November cover story, “The Next Wave of Hotel & Resort Restaurants.” Read the rest of the feature HERE.

Dellshire Blade and Barrel booth.
From thoughtfully crafted entrées to Wisconsin staples built on farm-forward ingredients, Blade & Barrel is designed to provide comfort while still having enough flair to intrigue the “adventurer.”

For Draper, the challenge has been stepping outside of his comfort zone and updating his knowledge of the continually evolving nature of what guests want. Twenty‑five years ago, a simple turkey wrap with cheese, lettuce, and a mayo packet was a local hit; today, food trends have shifted, so he leans on younger team members to stay current.  

At Dellshire Castle, Draper is channeling that evolution into playful, story-driven, interactive dishes. At Blade & Barrel, for example, guests get to choose their own “sword” or blade when ordering a steak; servers present a magnetic board of around eight different steak knives for them to choose from.  

“I don’t want this too heavily themed because I want it to be approachable by everybody, but it’s hard not to notice it and then appreciate it while you’re here because it is all very top-end stuff that we’re doing. Your steak knife isn’t going to bend,” Draper says. 

From thoughtfully crafted entrées to Wisconsin staples built on farm-forward ingredients, Blade & Barrel is designed to provide comfort while still having enough flair to intrigue the “adventurer.” There’s fun theming on the menu with sections like “Breakfast of the Realm,” “Knight’s Round Table,” and “Sire’s Sides,” while dinner entrees include options like a Medieval Double Burger, fried Northern walleye, and a seven-finger pork chop.  

But the shining jewel is the King’s Cleaver for Two ($225): a 42-ounce tomahawk ribeye that’s hung, flame-seared, and presented tableside with horseradish cream, steak sauce, and two bistro salads, plus two enhancements like roasted bone marrow butter or red chimichurri and chef’s seasonal farm accompaniments.  

Blade & Barrel - 42oz Hanging Tomahawk.
At Blade & Barrel, King’s Cleaver for Two features a 42-ounce tomahawk ribeye that’s flame-seared tableside.

Draper uses the King’s Cleaver experience as both a flashy showpiece in the dining room as well as a training tool for employees, who he says are often “pretty nervous” at first to go tableside and flambé the tomahawk with local Gold Bar Reserve bourbon and carve it in front of guests. So, he leads by example. “You just have to go out there and do it in front of them,” he says. “It’s just empowering them, making sure they have the resources.” 

He drills fundamentals like proper seasoning (“salt and pepper is magic”) and a service mindset that recognizes resort guests are literally “at home” on property, so food, service, and genuine care should provide comfort. While it’s challenging to instill that level of hospitality all the way down to line cooks and stewards, he feels they’re succeeding, noting reviews that praise those extra steps that make guests feel truly looked after. 

He also advises against “mile-long” menus that try to have something for everybody; he wants Dellshire’s restaurants to focus on fewer but genuinely great dishes. In the lobby, The Thirsty Dragon serves handcrafted cocktails and select shareable bites like tavern French onion soup, smoked whitefish dip, chicken wings, and cheese curds. Scale Cove, the adults-only swim-up bar, features in-water seating and a one-page menu of cocktails and snacks from handhelds and piña colada dip to nachos and the Walking Taco with Fritos, cheese sauce, sour cream, and fire-roasted salsa.  

Dellshire Resort - Serpent's Bay Scale Cove.
Serpent’s Bay Scale Cove at Dellshire Resort.

For Draper, dining is no longer just “I’m hungry, let’s eat,” but about creating a memorable experience that justifies what people spend. “Do you want them to come and remember what you did?” he emphasizes. 

Recognizing that the resort audience differs from a standalone restaurant, Draper is already cooking up plans to pivot the menu at Dawn Manor just a few months in, moving away from items like sea scallops toward more family-friendly, sharable dishes, with ideas like a chicken parmesan that’s presented tableside with sauce and melted cheese. 

Guest feedback is actively shaping the evolution as Draper and his team refine a menu that works for families across the property, including guests staying at the nearby Treetop Villas at Mirror Lake and resort visitors alike. The goal is to give adults enough good drinks and fun “munchy” food options while delighting children with interactive touches like a dragon-shaped pepperoni pizza package (pizza, cookies, and a “dinosaur egg” toy that hatches in water). “Give them that memory that they can take with them,” he says. 

The most rewarding part for Draper is walking into the dining room hallway and getting stopped by people who thank him and rave about the dining experience. “That’s kind of what we live off of. There’s a lot of people that do work for months on end, and then they see the final product. For me, I get gratification every 10 minutes,” he says.  

“Whether it’s good or bad, and if it’s bad, we can fix it. Let me make it right for you. I think that’s been a big push by our management, too. We want to make sure that we get that return; that’s important,” he adds. “We want to make sure that they feel like they’re at home.” 

Chef Profiles, Consumer Trends, Feature, Food, Hotel & Lodging, Labor & Employees, Menu Innovations