Resurrected Bennigan’s Plans its Second Act

This past year, Bennigan’s opened three U.S. restaurants: Steubenville, Ohio; Mandan, North Dakota; and Monahans, Texas. All three are experiencing double the sales volume of legacy units in a box that’s about half the size of the original 10,000-square-foot prototype. There are 18 international units as well. Bennigan’s executed a master franchise agreement with the Baila Group of Companies last year to expand into four major cities in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Other overseas locations are planned for Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, and Amsterdam. In total, Mangiamele says, more than 100 Bennigan’s are in some stage of development.

Same-store sales are tracking positive, too. After an initial burst, they’ve leveled out to about 3 percent, year-over-year. From a compounded-annual growth rate, average-unit volumes are tracking 40 percent higher since Mangiamele jumped in.

Small markets, big wins

As you can see from 2018’s openings, Bennigan’s current growth chart is centered on small markets with large trade areas. Instead of starting in big cities and moving out, Bennigan’s is debuting in smaller cities and coming in. There are a few reasons for this but it all returns to unit-level economics and profitable franchisees, Mangiamele says.

It’s cheaper land. More affordable rent. A quicker return on investment. The trade areas expand from a few blocks to 20, 30, 40 miles, “as soon as we open the doors,” he says.

One of the challenges faced by casual brands nationwide is the proliferation of convenience-driven options into the restaurant marketplace. Impulse diners simply don’t flock to sit-down chains like they used to. Look at the mall dynamic, for example. Brands like Maggiano’s and The Cheesecake Factory have weathered the retail crisis because they serve occasions, not foot traffic. Customers are targeting these brands, for birthdays, rehearsal dinners, nights out, instead of making a lunch-time decision to drop in.

Opening in a small market can mirror the effect, Mangiamele explains.

“If I open a Bennigan’s in Manhattan, it’s ho-hum, another restaurant,” Mangiamele says. “You open in Monahans, Texas, and it’s the biggest event of the century.” And, again, people will travel from much farther to reach a destination restaurant. They don’t need to be multi-tasking. The restaurant isn’t relying on real-estate connections like shopping centers, parking garages, and so on. “It’s a whole different dynamic,” Mangiamele says. “And one that has been able to generate very, very high volumes for those stores.”

It doesn’t hurt either that it’s Bennigan’s planting a flag, he adds. Regardless of what happened in 2008, the chain doesn’t lack for brand attraction. It even features trademarked menu items, like the Death by Chocolate dessert. Mangiamele says some of the recent openings have resulted in lines snaking around the building. “I know I’m often the victim of exaggeration, but I really, truly love the response to these brands. It’s humbling. To see people, honest to goodness, pressing their noses up against the glass, waiting for us to open. I tell them, cut the preshift short. Open the door. Let the guests in so we can serve them. They’ve been waiting long enough for us.”

Past being a brand of choice, Bennigan’s immediately becomes an employer of choice in these small markets. Staffing is currently facing one of the most challenging dynamics in restaurant history. Restaurant employment has grown by more than 1.8 percent, year-over-year, during the last two months, according to TDn2K. However, the number of vacancies that need to be filled because of turnover continues to rise. In December, the U.S. jobless rate rose to 3.9 percent from a 49-year low of 3.7 percent the previous month. That tightened market isn’t quite as laced up in some of these smaller towns, Mangiamele says. You don’t run into the ultra-competitive workplace battle you see in larger cities, where incentives, like flex hours and other gig benefits, are as valuable as dollar figures. When Bennigan’s drops down it creates a stir from the consumer to the worker to the operators.

Another reason this has been successful is that Bennigan’s remains selective in finding savvy, local entrepreneurs who are as passionate about the brand as Mangiamele is. Or at least in the same universe. In underserved markets, these operators know the lay of the land and how to market, and how to embed the brand into the community well past grand opening.

Mangiamele believes franchisees have benefited from this close structure, too. They’ve enjoyed the intimate relationship and back-and-forth Mangiamele provides from a very committed perch. He’s a CEO who also owns the company and has put all of his money on the win line. “That’s credibility that can’t be equaled with a lot of brands,” he says. Mangiamele has been on the other side, where he’s invested as a franchisee and hoped for franchisor support. “The way this works is: they make money, I open restaurants. It’s a beautiful formula,” he says. “I want them to feel the partnership and collaboration.”

Mangiamele says if you look at the company’s franchise disclosure documents, one thing is missing: litigation with franchisees.

“Why? Because we talk to them every week,” he says. “We see them all the time. We establish that emotional connection. Loyalty translates into focuses on the guest and focusing on more sales generation and then exploring ways to add to the revenue, whether it be delivery or catering. In-fighting is distracting to a restaurant company. And I try to avoid that.”

Sticking to what got you here

Mangiamele isn’t shy about sounding off on what’s wrong with the segment. Casual dining, for many brands, is suffering from “the insidious disease called brand drift,” he says. It’s what Mangiamele refers to as a “complete and utter abdication of the connection from the brand to the guest.”

“You’re saying, come on in, we’re full service, but help yourself,” he says. “That’s crazy. It’s just crazy. But I applaud every time any new brand rolls out something like that [kiosks and other service replacements] because I’ll just take those defected customers and I’ll put them in a Bennigan’s.”

“I’ve said this a million times,” Mangiamele adds. “But culture, people, and passion beat strategy and tactics every day of the week. I’ll go to the grave saying that.”

Back in the glory days of casual dining, Mangiamele says, the food was “pretty damn good.” The chains were doing ridiculously high volumes. But then they moved further and further away from their original success components. It’s why you see a lot of classic chains trying to return to past brand promises as opposed to reinventing new ones. “It’s going on nine years now that I’m fighting the good fight and bringing that panache, that fun, that value, that family-friendly atmosphere and vibe back into our brands.”

So what about some of the buzzier trends out there? Let’s take off-premises for example. Mangiamele says, simply, that casual dining lives and dies by a pretty straightforward premise: hot food is hot and cold food is cold. That’s the No. 1 commandment. Failing on that target has caused Mangiamele to be a bit hesitant on delivery. But he’s not ready to ignore it. Bennigan’s has worked on creating a menu that makes sense for the space. Deliberate choices like offering cold sandwiches and, instead of French fries, stocking bags of potato chips. Additionally, making sure they have canned soda in the back to give to take-out customers instead of fountain drinks.

Bennigan’s rolled out a catering initiative “that’s working very well.” And has different, in-house, big-party initiatives to satisfy larger events.

Another possible future channel could be retail, Mangiamele says. Similar to Goldbelly and the now-closed Carnegie Deli, Mangiamele sees opportunity in having its trademarked items distributed for delivery. “That adds to incremental sales and the overall system,” he says. “And it still builds brand awareness, which is all important.”

“Don’t win on price”

One casual-dining phenomenon lately has been higher check averages offsetting traffic declines. Or the opposite: value-based incentives driving traffic while cutting into franchisee’s profit margins. In Bennigan’s case, Mangiamele says, the chain has never tried to win on price. He fears the result of getting locked into discounting, and losing the key.

Bennigan’s instead works on value, he says. Value not in low price points but in abundance. The portions are large on purpose, Mangiamele says, so guests walk out with enough food for lunch. Then the sentiment becomes: this was a great deal, even if it cost $14. “OK, you now have two meals that cost you $7 each. Try to go to a fast-food place and get something similar. It doesn’t exist,” Mangiamele says.

He adds that, in his opinion, deep discounting cheapens the value of a brand. It creates confusion on the store level. Most traffic increases you see in full service these days? It’s because of delivery, Mangiamele says.

“If you look at in-store sales traffic, it’s down almost everywhere,” he says. “You have to continue to work on what’s happening inside your four walls as you work along these other initiatives. And if you can’t improve that, you’re going to suffer the consequences.”

The three Cs

Mangiamele says the restaurant industry is a fierce fight for market share, regardless of the category. You can work on everything, food quality, food safety, training, and so, and still break down. Mangiamele, in response, likes to keep the company’s mission statement simple and easy to comprehend.

Competence. Character. Culture.

“I’ve been lucky enough to stand on Norman Brinker’s shoulders and represent the only two brands he created during his career. I think that’s cool as hell,” Mangiamele says.

Corporate longevity has helped Bennigan’s guard those traits and promote company pride.

Shawn Finn, the company’s VP of operations, has been onboard since 1987. Its VP of supply chain and administration, Deanna Alder, since 1989. The average tenure at Bennigan’s, Mangiamele says, is more than 16 years.

“We have a mission and a purpose,” he says. “And the purpose is to live our brand 25/8. And to deliver flawless execution to go above and beyond the call of duty.”

When Mangiamele walks into a new restaurant one of the first things he does is ask the team, “What’s our mission.”

“Why are we here? What do you stand for? Because I think if a lot of teams don’t know that then, as a brand, you’re just marking time,” he adds. “That’s part of the exodus of different restaurants’ employees. They don’t know what they stand for. There is no mission. So they go, well, somebody offered me another 15 cents and they’re gone.”

The international pipeline

Bennigan’s has seen tremendous response overseas, Mangiamele says. The Middle east, South America, the chain continues to sign master deals with the intention of growing rapidly in new markets. Mangiamele says the demand for U.S. brands remains strong, and being flexible helped Bennigan’s thrive early on. About 10–15 percent of the menu can be curated so that Bennigan’s doesn’t end up trying “to out-local the locals,” Mangiamele says.

“I think a lot of other brands have made that mistake,” he says. You’re bringing your brand over but you’re trying to out-local the locals, which is a really bad idea. Bring an aspect of the local instead. Not only the cuisine and the menu, but even the way the restaurant is built.” One example is specs and sourcing. Whenever it makes more sense, Bennigan’s gets product. There’s no strict set of guidelines that stall the operation. A Larnaca, Cypress, restaurant, for example, sources meat from New Zealand.