Dining Room Activity
Although It’s Just Wings is a promising venture and off-premises mixes in the high 40 percent range, Chili’s knows it’s true strength lies with dining rooms.
To that end, Chili’s is making investments to ensure a fully integrated digital experience. Essentially, customers may use tabletop devices to order before the server arrives. The waiter will then see that, bring the food, and start the experience.
Roberts said it will improve table turns and the efficiency of servers. Those are side benefits, but both have key implications to the restaurant on a busy Friday or Saturday night.
“You’re off and running significantly faster,” Roberts said. “You can close out at the same time on that device and you eliminate some of the stretch points that can come into an occasion if you’re in a hurry. If you’re not, we’ve got servers there that will take your order and bring your experience to you at whatever pace you want. It allows you to control that more. We’re very excited about the opportunity to offer this to guests. We think it will pick up.”
As of January 20, 82 percent of Chili’s and 69 percent of Maggiano’s dining rooms were open. A big piece of news for the brands is California is now allowing outdoor dining. The Golden State has gone back and forth with dining room restrictions in the past year, but in the times it’s returned, the response has been immediate. The restaurants open parking lots, pitch tents, and watch as consumers begin to line up.
The CEO acknowledged that California has a COVID problem, but he believes the solution was unnecessarily heavy on restaurants and ineffective in stopping the crisis.
“When COVID’s over and you do the case studies of why a state that closed restaurants still has some of the worst results, it’s just interesting, right?” Roberts said. “It comes back to, if you’re running restaurants the right way, it’s not the driver of COVID, and I think California has felt that.”
Maggiano’s has suffered more from COVID restrictions. The second quarter is typically the brand’s strongest, but the pandemic eliminated its robust banquet and corporate catering channels. As a result, comps dropped 47 percent and traffic sank 37.8 percent in Q2. Operating income dropped from $21.5 million in fiscal 2020 to a loss of $900,000 in 2021, and operating margin decreased from 16.7 percent to 5.5 percent. The restaurant earned $64.3 million in total revenue, down from $126.2 million in fiscal 2020.
Comparatively, Chili’s traffic dipped 1.8 percent. Operating income slipped from $51.6 million to $50 million and operating margin decreased from 12.1 percent to 11.3 percent. Total revenue changed from $743.1 million last year to $696.4 million in 2021.
“With the second quarter now behind us, we expect the impact from Maggiano’s to consolidate the performance of Brinker to be more muted as we head into the rest of the fiscal year, particularly as the brand recovers from both an improved operating environment and the implementation of performance-driving initiatives,” Taylor said.
Brinker, parent of Chili's and Maggiano's, ended Q2 with 1,601 Chili’s stores—1,232 domestically and 369 internationally—and 54 Maggiano’s locations. Chili’s is projected to open 10 U.S. stores and six to nine international restaurants in fiscal 2021.
Taylor said Chili’s is reaching a point in its evolution where it can increase unit development. The brand previously indicated that it wants to reach 1 to 2 percent growth on an annual basis. The CFO said that should start as the company moves into 2023 and 2024.
“We’re seeing some changes in the real estate market,” Taylor said. “I think we are seeing conversion opportunities at a much higher level, which are interesting because I’m seeing our ability to access certain markets now that you probably wouldn’t have had the same level of access to pre-pandemic. I’m excited about that opportunity. We’re positioning the company so we can grow at that level from both a capital perspective and a team perspective.”
Approach to Minimum Wage Laws
President Joe Biden has made it clear that raising the minimum wage is a priority for his administration.
In fact, Democrats in both houses reintroduced a bill that would raise the federal minimum wage from $7.25 to $15 by 2025. The current level has remained in place since 2009.
Chili’s appears well-suited to take on the potential change since its No. 2, No. 3, and No. 4 markets have all increased minimum wage beyond the federal requirement.
Roberts said in states with higher labor costs, restaurants leverage technology to create efficiency, which allows employees to make more money because the tip pool is spread among fewer people.
The brand also looks at ways to be more effective around tip pooling. Roberts explained in these higher-cost situations, the company can mitigate extra expenses by letting the tip pooling bring up wages.
The CEO feels Chili’s has an advantage because other brands will have to deal with the wage pressures from a pricing perspective. For example, Chili’s is able to utilize its 3 for $10 deal in California despite the minimum wage being $15 and the elimination of the tip credit wage.
“How long we can afford that price point in that market, I don’t know,” Roberts said. “But it is out there and it has been out there for a couple of years even as the price and the wage rates have gone up. So I think our scale really helps us in this environment. And at the end of the day, these things across the industry are going to be much more difficult for restaurant operators.”
“… The way you deal with this most effectively is through technology and through systems, and we have the ability to do that and have been doing that. And we are excited about rolling some of this technology to other markets fairly soon.”
At Chili’s, servers average around $20 when tips are included; the average is closer to $30 in California.
Taylor said he doesn’t think anything will change in this fiscal year or even the next, but Brinker will move forward with the assumption that something will happen in the future.
“This will be a debate,” Taylor said. “I think it is going to be front and center for an extended period of time this year. I have been involved in a couple of minimum wage debates over the years, and they do tend to be intense discussions. There is passion on both sides of the equation. They tend to extend over periods of time.”