Schwartz shares Tinoco’s sentiment. “If the sommeliers, servers, and staff understand dessert wine, these wines will sell. There definitely is an opportunity to boost dessert wine sales through by-the-glass, half-glass, or bottle [options],” he says. And it doesn’t hurt to grab customers’ eyes with a catchy headline on the wine list like “Sticky and Sweet,” as Frasca does, or to promote dessert wines by pairing them on tasting and holiday menus, as Frasca and Chefs Club do.
“With some menus, we have printed dessert wine pairings under each dish—that at least plants the seed in the guest’s mind that they should try a dessert wine,” Levens says. “Pouring guests a little complimentary taste is also a great way to gently educate and give them an opportunity to get to know the wines.”
Chef, bartender, and corporate sommelier for iPic Entertainment, Adam Seger, who boasts an extensive collection of Madeira wine at The Tuck Room in New York, says the same. “People don’t really order [dessert wine,] but once they try it, they like it,” he says. Seger delights in regaling guests with the history of Madeira and tying it into the location of The Tuck Room in the historic Seaport District. “If you lived in New York in the 18th or 19th centuries, you either drank ale or Madeira,” he says, explaining that Madeira withstood the tumultuous ocean voyages to the New World. It was the wine used to celebrate George Washington’s inauguration and the signing of the Declaration of Independence and the Louisiana Purchase.
When pairing dessert wines with food, it helps to have some guidelines, advises Levens.
“With dessert, I always use the rule that the wine must be as sweet as or sweeter than the dessert,” Levens says. “Port and Madeira are both great with chocolate and great on their own, as well, in the place of dessert.” But the most popular dessert wine at Chefs Club is definitely Moscato. “When I have a Moscato [on the menu], it moves the most,” Levens says. “I think people feel familiar with it, it’s usually gently sparkling and gently sweet and not too expensive.”
Schwartz starts with tried and true food and wine matches. “Some classic dessert wine pairings include Sauternes and foie gras, Port and blue cheese, Banyuls and chocolate, Moscato d’Asti and fruit-based desserts/tarts,” Schwartz says. At Frasca, he recommends a 2011 Villa Spinosa Recioto della Valpolicella Classico with the restaurant’s Baba Napoletano, which is a dessert made with brioche cake, coffee, chocolate, and cherry. “Or something super simple like 2009 Badia a Coltibuono Vin Santo del Chianti Classico with a single biscotti,” he says.
Tinoco matches a mascarpone cheesecake with a grapefruit-lemon swirl sorbet and brown sugar crumble with a glass of 2015 Wente Vineyards Orange Muscat. For a dark chocolate mousse dish with white chocolate crème, orange, and toasted hazelnuts, he pairs Quinta do Noval Black Ruby Port. And for a cream puff with apple compote, vanilla whipped panna cotta, and caramel, he recommends 2011 Clos Guirouilh, Petit Cuyalaa, Jurançon.
Incorporating dessert wines into cocktails can help boost their popularity with customers, too. On his cocktail list, Seger has incorporated Madeira into two cocktails: Govna’, which also includes rum, spiced New York ginger apple liqueur, and pimento bitters, and The Esquire, which is Malmsey Madeira on hand-cut ice with wood-fired evaporated maple and fresh nutmeg.
Perry’s Steakhouse and Grille in Chicago, where Susi Zivanovic serves as corporate sommelier and beverage director, used Valentine’s Day as a hook to promote dessert wines. The restaurant concocted cocktails like the PassionNut for Port featuring Fonseca Bin No. 27 Port with Don Q coconut rum, passion fruit puree, and lemon juice and encouraged customers to order one of the restaurant’s 18 dessert wines instead of actual dessert. “There is more complexity in fortified and dessert wines than table wines because of the elaborate winemaking techniques used,” says Zivanovic. “This lends unique characteristics that pair perfectly alongside rich flavors, such as desserts, or can be enjoyed alone as a dessert.”